Cold Case Investigations

Death of Edgar Allan Poe

Calling all Las Vegas amateur detectives! Come watch a short video(s) and then discuss and debate the facts of the case in an attempt to determine the killer(s).

Oct 6 Edgar Allan Poe

Facts of the Case: Death of Edgar Allan Poe

Date and Place of Death: Edgar Allan Poe, aged 40, died on October 7, 1849, at approximately 5:00 a.m. (some accounts vary slightly to 3:00 a.m.) at Washington College Hospital (also referred to as Washington Medical College) in Baltimore, Maryland.

Official Reported Cause: No death certificate is known to exist (none was required at the time), and no autopsy was performed. Contemporary reports listed the cause as “congestion of the brain,” “inflammation of the brain,” or “phrenitis” (an antiquated term for brain swelling or encephalitis-like symptoms). These were common euphemisms or catch-all diagnoses when the precise cause was unclear.

Timeline of Known Events:

September 27, 1849: Poe departed Richmond, Virginia, intending to travel to Philadelphia and then New York for literary business (editing a volume of poems). He was reportedly sober and in good spirits when he left.
September 28, 1849: Poe arrived in Baltimore. His activities and whereabouts for the next several days (nearly a week) remain unknown. He did not proceed to his intended destinations.
October 3, 1849 (Election Day): Poe was found in a semiconscious, delirious state outside Gunner’s Hall (Ryan’s 4th Ward Polls), a tavern/polling place in Baltimore. He was wearing shabby, ill-fitting clothes that were not his own and appeared unkempt. Printer Joseph W. Walker recognized him, contacted mutual acquaintance Dr. J.E. Snodgrass, and Poe was transported to the hospital.
October 3–7, 1849 (Hospital Stay): At the hospital under Dr. John J. Moran’s care, Poe exhibited delirium, hallucinations, sweating, confusion, and periods of unconsciousness. He reportedly called out for “Reynolds” (identity unknown) and, near the end, uttered “Lord help my poor soul.” He had limited or no visitors; accounts note he was too excitable for some. He never provided a coherent explanation of the preceding days.

Key Facts and Context:

Poe had a history of intermittent alcohol use and sensitivity to it, but scholars dispute the notion of him as a chronic heavy drinker or opium addict. He had sworn off alcohol for periods and was reportedly sober shortly before the trip.
No clear evidence of foul play, suicide, or specific toxins was documented at the time.
He was buried hastily in an unmarked grave at Westminster Burying Ground in Baltimore, with few attendees.

Status of the Case: The precise cause of death and circumstances of the missing days remain undetermined and disputed. No definitive medical records survive. Over two dozen theories exist, including alcohol-related issues (intoxication or withdrawal), cooping (electoral fraud involving drugging and forced voting, fitting the election-day tavern location and strange clothes), beating/robbery, rabies, brain tumor, heart disease, epilepsy, carbon monoxide poisoning, and others. None has been conclusively proven; the evidence is fragmentary and often contradictory due to inconsistent later accounts by witnesses like Dr. Moran.

This remains one of American literature’s enduring mysteries—fittingly macabre for the master of the genre.

Jan 6 Benjamin "Bugsy" Siegel

Feb 3 Pope John Paul I

Mar 3 Hinterkaifeck Murders

Apr 7 Princess Diana

May 5 Jimmy Hoffa

Jun 2 Natalie Wood

Jul 7 Sonny Liston

Aug 4 Alexander the Great

Sep 1 Marilyn Monroe

Oct 6 Edgar Allan Poe

Nov 3 Pharaoh Ramesses III

Dec 1 Sodder Children Disappearance

Seating is on a first-come, first-served basis.

Free & open to the public.

Call 702.507.3427 for more information.

Upcoming events